Punishment versus Discipline

The concept of discipline is often mistaken for the term punishment. But the punishment and the discipline, have very involve very differnt methods of attitudes and actions.

Punishment

Discipline


Emphasizes what a child should not do

Emphasizes what a child should do.

Is a one time occurrence.

Is an ongoing process.

Insists on obedience.

Sets and example to follow.

Undermines independence

Leads to self-control

Is an adult release and about their power. It is also often about displaced anger. This is when adults are angry about something else but take their anger out on children.

Helps children change.

Is negative

Is positive

Makes children behave

Accepts child’s need to assert self

Defeats self esteem

Encourages self esteem

Condemns misbehavior

Encourages self disciplined behavior.

[1]



[1] Alternatives to Corporal Punishment: The Learning Experience. A Practical Guide for Educators to Develop and Maintain a Culture of Discipline, Dignity, and Respect in the Classroom. South African Department of Education.